LC · Higher Level · Business
Industrial Relations
Industrial Relations is the study of the relationship between employers and employees, and the systems and processes used to manage their interactions, especially when disagreements or disputes arise. It focuses on achieving a balance between the interests of management and the workforce.
Core Concepts
-
Parties in Industrial Relations:
- Employers: Businesses or organisations that provide employment.
- Employees: Individuals who work for an employer.
- Trade Unions: Organisations that represent employees' interests, negotiate on their behalf, and protect their rights.
- Employer Associations: Organisations that represent and advise employers.
- State Agencies: Bodies established by the government to help resolve disputes and promote good industrial relations, such as the Workplace Relations Commission (WRC) and the Labour Court.
-
Causes of Industrial Disputes (2014 HL P1 p6):
- Pay and Conditions: Disagreements over wages, salaries, bonuses, working hours, holidays, and other benefits.
- Redundancy: Disputes arising from job losses, selection criteria for redundancy, or the terms of severance packages.
- Unfair Dismissal or Discrimination: Employees feeling unjustly treated, dismissed without proper cause, or discriminated against based on gender, age, religion, etc.
- Technological Change: Introduction of new technology that may lead to job displacement, retraining needs, or changes in work practices.
- Trade Union Recognition: Employers refusing to recognise or negotiate with a trade union representing their employees.
-
Types of Industrial Action (Employees):
- Official Industrial Action: Action sanctioned by a trade union, following a secret ballot of its members and giving due notice to the employer. This action has legal protection under the Industrial Relations Act 1990.
- Unofficial Industrial Action: Action taken by employees without the sanction of their trade union or without following legal procedures. This action does not have legal protection.
- Picketing:
- Primary Picketing: Employees standing or patrolling outside their own employer's premises during a dispute to inform the public and deter others from entering. This is generally lawful under the Industrial Relations Act 1990 (2015 HL P1 p4).
- Secondary Picketing: Picketing at the premises of an employer not directly involved in the dispute. This is only lawful under very strict conditions, specifically if the second employer is directly frustrating the primary industrial action (2015 HL P1 p4).
- Strikes: A collective refusal by employees to work. Types include:
- All-out Strike: Complete cessation of work by all employees.
- Work-to-Rule: Employees strictly adhere to their contract of employment and job description, often slowing down work.
- Go-Slow: Employees deliberately work at a reduced pace.
- Token Stoppage: A short, symbolic strike to highlight a grievance.
- Boycott: Employees and/or their supporters refuse to buy or use the products or services of the employer in dispute.
-
Types of Industrial Action (Employers):
- Lock-out: An employer refuses to allow employees to work during a dispute, effectively preventing them from earning wages.
-
Resolving Industrial Disputes:
- Internal Procedures: Negotiation between management and employees/unions, or formal grievance procedures within the company.
- External (Third-Party) Intervention:
- Workplace Relations Commission (WRC): Established in 2015, the WRC took over the functions of the Labour Relations Commission (LRC), National Employment Rights Authority (NERA), and the Equality Tribunal.
- Functions of the former Labour Relations Commission (LRC) (2014 HL P1 p4):
- Conciliation: A neutral third party (Conciliation Officer) brings the disputing parties together to help them find a mutually acceptable solution. The conciliator does not impose a solution.
- Mediation: A neutral third party (Mediator) actively assists the parties in exploring options and reaching a settlement. This is a more interventionist role than conciliation.
- Advisory Service: Providing advice and guidance on best practice in industrial relations.
- Codes of Practice: Developing guidelines on various aspects of industrial relations.
- Rights Commissioner Service: Investigating individual employment disputes (now handled by WRC Adjudication Officers).
- Labour Court: The court of last resort for industrial disputes. It hears appeals from WRC decisions and issues recommendations, which are not legally binding but are generally accepted by parties.
Key Definitions and Functions
| Term / Function | Description | Relevant Act / Context |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Picketing | Picketing at the premises of the employer directly involved in the dispute. | Industrial Relations Act 1990 |
| Secondary Picketing | Picketing at the premises of an employer not directly involved in the dispute. Lawful only if that employer directly frustrates the primary action. | Industrial Relations Act 1990 |
| Official Industrial Action | Industrial action sanctioned by a trade union after a secret ballot of its members, and with due notice given to the employer. | Industrial Relations Act 1990 |
| WRC Conciliation | A neutral third party (WRC Conciliation Officer) helps disputing parties reach a voluntary agreement. | Workplace Relations Act 2015 (formerly LRC function) |
| WRC Mediation | A neutral third party (WRC Mediator) actively assists parties in exploring solutions and reaching a settlement. | Workplace Relations Act 2015 (formerly LRC function) |
How it Appears in the Exam
Industrial Relations questions often require you to:
- Distinguish between different concepts (e.g., primary vs. secondary picketing) (2015 HL P1 p4).
- Outline or explain factors that lead to disputes or functions of state bodies (2014 HL P1 p6, 2014 HL P1 p4).
- Discuss types of industrial action available to employees (2014 HL P1 p6).
- These questions typically require clear definitions, explanations, and sometimes examples.
Worked Example
Question: Distinguish between primary picketing and secondary picketing as types of industrial action available to employees. (2015 HL P1 p4)
Solution:
To distinguish between primary and secondary picketing, it's important to define each and highlight their key differences, particularly regarding their legality and location.
-
Primary Picketing:
- Definition: This occurs when employees picket at the premises of their own employer, who is directly involved in the industrial dispute. The purpose is to publicise the dispute and persuade others (e.g., customers, suppliers) not to deal with the employer.
- Legality: Primary picketing is generally lawful under the Industrial Relations Act 1990, provided it is peaceful and takes place at or near the place where the employer works or carries on business. It must also be in contemplation or furtherance of a trade dispute.
-
Secondary Picketing:
- Definition: This occurs when employees picket at the premises of an employer who is not directly involved in the industrial dispute.
- Legality: Secondary picketing is only lawful under very strict and limited circumstances as defined by the Industrial Relations Act 1990. It is only permitted if the second employer is directly frustrating the primary industrial action taken against the first employer. This means the second employer must be actively undermining the effectiveness of the primary picketing or strike. If this condition is not met, secondary picketing is unlawful and can lead to legal action against the picketers and their union.
Key Distinction: The fundamental difference lies in the employer being picketed and the legal conditions for the action. Primary picketing targets the employer in dispute and is generally lawful. Secondary picketing targets a third-party employer and is only lawful if that third party is actively frustrating the primary action.
Common Pitfalls
[!WARNING] Confusing Official vs. Unofficial Action: Students often forget the legal implications. Official industrial action is sanctioned by a union after a ballot and has legal protection. Unofficial action lacks this protection, leaving employees vulnerable to legal action or dismissal.
[!IMPORTANT] Misunderstanding Secondary Picketing Legality: Remember that secondary picketing is rarely lawful. The condition that the second employer must be directly frustrating the primary action is very specific and difficult to prove. Do not assume it is generally allowed.
[!WARNING] Mixing up WRC and Labour Court Roles: The WRC handles initial conciliation, mediation, and adjudication of disputes. The Labour Court acts as an appeals body and issues recommendations, which are not legally binding but are almost always followed. They have distinct roles in the dispute resolution process.
Exam Tips
- Define Key Terms: Always start by clearly defining any industrial relations terms mentioned in the question (e.g., "industrial dispute," "picketing").
- Use Examples: Illustrate your points with practical examples where possible to demonstrate understanding.
- Refer to Legislation: Mentioning the Industrial Relations Act 1990, especially for questions on picketing or official action, shows depth of knowledge.
- Structure Your Answers: For "distinguish" questions, use a clear comparative structure (e.g., define A, define B, then state differences). For "outline" or "discuss" questions, use bullet points or clear paragraphs.
- Stay Current: While past questions mention the Labour Relations Commission (LRC), remember that its functions are now primarily carried out by the Workplace Relations Commission (WRC). It's good practice to mention the WRC as the current body.